Those who want to ditch the UK for the EU should support Prospective Prime Minister Miliband, the most Europhile member of the Cabinet. We are going through seismic changes in Europe and if Miliband becomes Prime Minister it may all be over for the UK.
The next two years are crucial for our independence. The ratchet clause in the Lisbon Treaty will make it self-amending – Westminster’s approval will never again be needed for Europe to extend its powers. This, and the possibility of being outvoted in the EU on virtually every issue, signifies the end of our self-determination.
For the time being the Irish No stops the Lisbon Treaty from taking effect. Most of the other countries are ratifying it anyway and trying to bully the Irish into submission. The Conservatives will hold a referendum if the Treaty has not yet been adopted by all 27 countries when they win power – but the likely 2010 election may come after Ireland concedes and the Treaty becomes law. Prime Minister Miliband may be succeded by Governor Cameron.
Miliband’s utterances on Europe show that he has inherited Tony Blair’s cynicism. He rejects the European superstate but accepts the Lisbon Treaty which creates it. He was also the apologist-in-chief for Labour’s breach of its referendum promise.
In October 2007 Miliband wrote Global Europe, in which he set out the EU’s future strategy. The UK is rarely mentioned, and Miliband speaks as if he represents Europe. “We” means “We, Europeans”, not “We, Brits”. He muses that institutional reform is now behind us, so “We” can tackle new challenges.
Miliband’s love for the EU shows in the Europhile blindness of the
document. He repeats the Europhile myths. There is the
flogged-to-death horse of Europe Bringing Post War Peace (ignoring that
many non EU nation states did not wage war on each other either).
Without much evidence Mr. Miliband states that Europe is responsible
for our prosperity over the last fifty years (when countries just
outside it had higher growth). There is the assertion that Lisbon was
needed to make Europe workable (whereas in the ten years prior to
Lisbon the EU overregulated at the greatest speed ever).
Sometimes Mr. Miliband confuses his wishes with reality. He talks about
“shared European values” such as free trade and open markets. He must
be the only person who still thinks that a belief in free world trade
and open markets is shared by, for example, France.
Miliband’s activist agenda shows Europe the way. Europe must get
busier in trade and competition policy, development, economic growth,
social policies, jobs, security, tackling organised crime, the
environment, financial markets, climate change and energy security. In
July he ditched Britain’s traditional resistance to a European army.
He now claims that the European army is no army (as he claimed the
constitution was no constitution).
Prime Minister Miliband’s government will bend over backwards to please
our EU friends. His document bears the seeds of the U-turns to come.
On the one hand he preaches a flexible labour market, on the other he
pleads for security. He wants to make Europe more competitive but
enthuses about Europe’s social values. He wants to liberalise world
trade, but qualifies it by saying that it must be equitable and that
“everybody” must show flexibility (so we can blame the US). He wants
to reduce regulation but puts it under the heading “Better Regulation”.
David Miliband likes EU spending, too. He wants to increase the
largely ineffective development aid. He wants to reform the Common
Agricultural Policy and phase out direct subsidies to farmers and price
support but does not say that the savings should go to reduce the EU
budget. He wants to increase European funding for poor European
regions which are failing through lack of reform. He wants more
European spending on research and innovation – ignoring the recent
study by Dr. Terence Kealey showing that state aid to R&D is
In summary: If Miliband becomes PM, there is a greater chance that
Lisbon will become law. This effectively ends our independence. In
addition, he believes in extending Europe’s powers, as is shown by his
activist agenda. Miliband is sound on free world trade, but his
lover’s blindness prevents him from seeing that this is unlikely ever
to command a majority in European negotiations.
But all’s not lost. Even in Labour there are people who do not want to get rid of the UK.
If you would like to write for Platform please click here.