Published:

75 comments

We’ve just had the results of the vote on the Lords amendment which sought to commit the UK to EEA membership. The overall result was the amendment was rejected by 327 votes to 126, but the interesting story is that Labour managed to split three ways on the topic.

Labour’s whipped position was to abstain, much to the frustration of Stephen Kinnock and a band of pro-EEA MPs on the opposition benches. Their expected rebellion in favour of the EEA amendment materialised – and how, with 74 rebels plus one teller, including five Opposition frontbenchers who resigned in order to back the amendment. They were joined by three Conservative rebels, whose names are no great surprise: Ken Clarke, Anna Soubry and Dominic Grieve. (I’ve listed all the rebels from each main party on both sides of the issue below, for the record.)

However, more surprising is the scale of the simultaneous Labour rebellion to vote against the EEA: 15 Labour MPs voted with the Government, including one (Laura Smith, Crewe and Nantwich), who quit as a Shadow Cabinet Office minister to do so.

As well as bringing the total number of resignations from Corbyn’s front bench past 100, this means a total of 90 Labour MPs rebelled in one direction or the other over the EEA tonight – rebelling against an abstention policy which was supposedly chosen in order to minimise rebellion. That’s more than a third of the Parliamentary Labour Party, a figure which won’t heal Tory bruises from yesterday’s events but will at least draw some of the sting from Opposition politicians’ gloating tweets about disunity on the Government benches.

In short, then, Labour whipped its MPs not to vote at all, but some rebelled by voting for the EEA, and some rebelled by voting against the EEA. Meanwhile, there was also a small Conservative rebellion in favour of the EEA.

Here are the rebels on each side of the issue, by party:

Conservative Pro-EEA rebels

Ken Clarke

Dominic Grieve

Anna Soubry

 

Labour Pro-EEA rebels

Teller: Susan Elan Jones

Rushanara Ali

Tonia Antoniazzi

Hilary Benn

Luciana Berger

Ben Bradshaw

Chris Bryant

Karen Buck

Richard Burden

Ruth Cadbury

Ann Coffey

Neil Coyle

Mary Creagh

Stella Creasy

Geraint Davies

Stephen Doughty

Rosie Duffield

Maria Eagle

Julie Elliott

Louise Ellman

Paul Farrelly

Mike Gapes

Roger Godsiff

Kate Green

John Grogan

Helen Hayes

Meg Hillier

George Howarth

Rupa Huq

Darren Jones

Helen Jones

Liz Kendall

Ged Killen

Stephen Kinnock

Peter Kyle

David Lammy

Chris Leslie

Seema Malhotra

Kerry McCarthy

Siobhain McDonagh

Pat McFadden

Conor McGinn

Alison McGovern

Catherine McKinnell

Anna McMorrin

Madeleine Moon

Ian Murray

Albert Owen

Jess Phillips

Bridget Phillipson

Ellie Reeves

Rachel Reeves

Emma Reynolds

Joan Ryan

Virendra Sharma

Barry Sheerman

Gavin Shuker

Tulip Siddiq

Andy Slaughter

Angela Smith

Owen Smith

Alex Sobel

Jo Stevens

Wes Streeting

Gareth Thomas

Stephen Timms

Anna Turley

Chuka Umunna

Catherine West

Matt Western

Martin Whitfield

Paul Williams

Phil Wilson

Daniel Zeichner

 

Labour Anti-EEA rebels

Kevin Barron

Ronnie Campbell

Rosie Cooper

Frank Field

Jim Fitzpatrick

Caroline Flint

Mike Hill

Kate Hoey

Kevan Jones

John Mann

Dennis Skinner

Laura Smith

Gareth Snell

John Spellar

Graham Stringer

75 comments for: Labour splits three ways over the EEA – including 15 MPs voting with the Government

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.