The phrase is Tim Montgomerie’s. He used to deploy it roughly as follows. Yes, politics means making choices. But they doesn’t always have to be either/or. The Conservatives can have immigration control and international development. Green growth and more fracking. Same-sex marriage and transferable tax allowances.
The new majority Tory Government won’t necessarily smile on these examples. But it will want to follow the principle. To this end, ConservativeHome is reviving The Politics Of And. In one series, we will examine Securing the Majority. In another, Growing the Majority. Boris Johnson will want to do both.
– – –
So Cimate Change is to come out of the Business Department. And Trade to go back in. And DfID to go back into the Foreign Office. And immigration to come out of the Home Office. Or so the briefing tells us.
Yet nothing very much is apparent yet on how to respond to the bad Conservative election result in Scotland. The Party is down by seats by more than half – from 13 to six.
It’s all the other way round in Wales, where the Tory representation is up from eight seats to fourteen. The Party won 36 per cent of the vote, only five per cent less than Labour.
Meanwhile, the two main parties in Northern Ireland, the Democratic Unionist Party and Sinn Fein, performed poorly. As David Shiels noted recently on this site, the province saw an anti-Brexit, anti-absentionist vote.
Leaving the EU will see new opportunities and challenges for the United Kingdom as a whole.
In Scotland, the new Government says No to a second independence referendum. Good. That argument will be harder to sustain if the SNP sweep the board in next year’s Scottish Parliament elections.
In Wales, the new Secretary of State, Simon Hart, and the Conservatives in the Welsh Assembly have new opportunities in a country whose electoral flavour is now more like, say, the Midlands than Scotland.
In Northern Ireland, there will be a settlement that leaves the province in much of the Single Market and with new east-west regulatory provision,
The new Government needs to think and act across the three territorial departments.
It also needs to harmonise whatever it does with continuing reform in England, which now hosts a sprawling patchwork of councils, mayors, police and crime commissioners.
Downing Street is mulling Lords reform to to give the UK’s constituent nations a greater stake at Westminster. Reform will be part of the remit of the Constitution, Democracy and Rights Commission announced in the manifesto.
Who will be in charge of shaping the Government’s response? There is a Minister for the Constitution – Chloe Smith, now re-elected with an increased majority in Norwich North.
She is part of the Cabinet Office team, at the head of which sits Michael Gove who, as Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, has been in charge of No Deal preparations.
He will require a new role after January 31.
So the obvious move is to make him Secretary of State for the Constitution, leading the media fightback against the SNP, forming policy for the UK as a whole and perhaps continuing working out of the Cabinet Office.
There is interest in Downing Street in some of these ideas, such as promoting the Union more proactively, and one move it might make it is to appoint Lord Caine to the Northern Ireland Office. Or to this new department.
We must resist the urge to recommend Gove as the solution to every presentational and policy problem.
But it is hard to think of another senior politician at Cabinet level with the necessary policy and presentational oomph, and who can work with the Welsh Conservatives, plus Jackson Carlaw and the Scottish Tories.
There may also be new post-Brexit opportunities for the Party in Northern Ireland. For example, it is clear that there is a potential opening for a non-DUP pro-Union party in North Down.